Following from my irritation with loading an OPML feed list into nimiq yesterday, I’ve come to a more general conclusion. Podcast software should simply never make noises.
This may sound a bit harsh - after all, audio output is an accepted part of many applications. Windows warbles when it starts up; my FTP application spits out boings, chirps, and beeps to remind me when transfers have finished, or logins fail, and many applications issue a summary “plonk” if anything goes wrong. But I reckon that a whole lot of people never hear these noises. Why? because they run their PCs with sound turned off. I know I do.
But here’s the kicker. Podcasting finally offers a reason to turn those speakers back on or plug in those headphones. Then what do you find? it’s almost impossible to get through a single podcast without irritating bleeps and twangs from some piece of software. And many of these bits of software are even aimed at podcast listeners!
In my mind, there is no justification for the casual use of sound alerts in any software that is at all concerned with audio. And that includes podcatchers, audio sequencers, MP3 and ID3 browsers and editors, and anything else used in podcasting. After all, anyone using the software is almost guaranteed to want to listen to audio using the same machine at some point.
Authors of software take note. If your software is useful for anything to do with audio (and that includes podcasting), it should run silent.
I guess this was a bit of a rant. Needed to be said, though.